Midterm Project Peer Review
Important
Counts for 2% of the final grade.
Due before class Week 8
You will be randomly assigned a Midterm Project from one of your fellow students. Use the issues page on that project's GitHub repository to log your comments/questions/suggestions/bugs. Create a separate "issue" for each observation.
Comment on both Design/UX issues and Code Quality issues, e.g. formatting, readability, comments. Remember to keep the tone positive and constructive.
When you have completed your review, submit a link to that GitHub issues page for the repository of the MidTerm Project that you have been assigned to review.
Evaluation Criteria
Graded out of a maximum score of 10 points.
| Rubric | 3 | 2 | 1 | 0 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Design Comments | Design comments provide clear helpful suggestions | Design comments are provided but some are incomplete or unclear | Very little feedback and/or ignored obvious issues | Not provided |
| Technical / Code Comments | Code comments provide clear helpful suggestions | Code comments are provided but some are incomplete or unclear | Very little feedback and/or ignored obvious issues | Not provided |
| Format | Clearly labeled issues, with well thought out comments. | Good separation of issues but some topic names or descriptions are not clear. | No clear labeling and/or mixed multiple topics into a single issue. | |
| Tone | Positively constructive suggestions | Some combative or dismissive language. | Significant amounts of inappropriate language or overly negative in tone. |